Why do some companies charge double for the same product or service and have a waiting list, while others offer aggressive discounts, burn margins, and barely survive?
The answer rarely lies in the ad algorithm or the intrinsic quality of the product; it almost always lies in positioning. When a brand fails to clearly articulate the unique value it delivers, the customer is forced to use the most primary differentiation criterion available: price. But your product or service is, most likely, not a commodity.
KEY CONCEPT
Commodity
A product or service that has become undifferentiated in the customer’s eyes. When brands fail to communicate unique value, consumers stop seeing differences between options and begin deciding exclusively based on the lowest price. A commodity does not compete on merit, quality, or transformation; it competes solely on cost.
Classic Example: Oil. Whether extracted by Exxon, BP, or Galp, the chemical substance is identical. Since there is no perceived difference, the price is dictated exclusively by the global market, with little room for a brand premium.
Everyday Example: Wheat flour in a supermarket. For most buyers, a 1kg pack of Type 65 flour is the same as any other. In the absence of a story, specific origin, or unique benefit, the purchasing decision inevitably falls on the cheapest option on the shelf.
This is the commoditization trap, where companies compete in a race to the bottom, destroying their own profitability under the illusion that sales volume will compensate for the lack of margin. The truth is that paid traffic and marketing campaigns only amplify the positioning that already exists. If the positioning is weak or confusing, marketing only accelerates the perception that your product is a commodity, easily replaced by an equivalent.
The fundamental error of many companies is trying to please everyone. In the eagerness not to leave money on the table, they broaden their offer, dilute their message, and try to be everything to everyone. The result is generic communication that resonates with no one. Strategic positioning demands exactly the opposite: it requires the courage to define clearly who you do not sell to, just as much as who you do.
When a company specializes in a specific niche, solves a very concrete problem, and speaks the exact language of that segment, it stops competing on price and starts competing on perceived value. A specialist in “marketing for dental clinics” can charge significantly more than a “general marketing agency,” not because they are technically better at everything, but because the client perceives that they understand the specific context, regulations, and exact pain points of that sector. Specificity generates trust, and trust justifies a price premium.
Regaining pricing power begins by redefining the value proposition. It is not about listing technical features or awards won, but about clearly articulating the unique transformation your company provokes in the customer’s life. You must answer the question: “Why would a customer choose us, even if we are more expensive?” If the answer is not obvious and convincing within five seconds, the positioning is not clear.
The solution lies in identifying your product or service’s “unique mechanism” – that specific approach that only your solution has – and placing it at the center of all communication. Stop talking about yourself and start talking about the specific problem you solve and the concrete improvement you deliver. When the customer perceives that your product is the only logical solution to their problem, price becomes secondary.
Many leaders confuse positioning with creative slogans, modern logos, or expensive branding campaigns. This is a dangerous illusion. Positioning does not happen in your presentation slides or brand manual; it happens exclusively in the customer’s mind. It is an exogenous process of induction. If, when a potential customer thinks of a product category, your brand is not one of the first to come to mind for solving a specific problem, then your positioning is weak, regardless of how stylish your website or communication may be.
Building solid positioning requires radical consistency over time. It is not about changing the message with every new market trend or seasonal campaign, but about repeating the same unique value proposition tirelessly, across all channels. From phone support to billing, from blog content to how the sales team handles an objection, everything must reinforce the same narrative of specialization and unique value. The clearer and more consistent your message is about who you serve and how you serve them, the less energy the customer will spend trying to understand you, and the faster they will move to purchase. Clarity beats style or sophistication in any market scenario.
However, a crystal-clear value proposition is useless if it withers in a marketing team’s PowerPoint. Positioning is fragile; it collapses if there is a disconnect between what is promised and what is delivered by the different “arms” of the organization.
- If marketing communicates specialization and premium value, but the sales team panics and offers aggressive discounts to close the month, the positioning is broken internally.
- If customer support treats all interactions as low-value transactions, without the empathy and expertise that a premium positioning requires, trust is corroded at the base.
- Management, in turn, must ensure that incentives, goals, and company culture reward the defense of this positioning, not selling at any cost.
The customer does not care about departments or teams, they see the brand/company as a whole, as a single entity. If the left hand (sales) devalues what the right hand (marketing) has built, the market is sensitive to this dissonance. Strong positioning requires that the entire company, from the intern to the CEO, rows in the same direction, speaking the same language and defending the same values. Without this operational alignment, strategy is just a beautiful (and expensive) document in a drawer.
If your company is stuck in a price war it cannot escape, Grow Beyond can help you work on the strategic repositioning of your product or service, so you can charge what you are truly worth and attract the right customers to your business.
Leave a Reply